русский
The simple answer is that valves can be, and frequently are, both forged and cast. The choice between these two manufacturing methods depends heavily on the valve's intended application, the required material properties, design complexity, and cost considerations. Both processes have distinct advantages and disadvantages that dictate their suitability for various valve types and service conditions.
1. Forged Valves
Process: Forging involves shaping solid metal (typically billets or bars) through localized compressive forces exerted by hammers, presses, or rolling machines. This is done while the metal is in a heated, but still solid, state. The key aspect of forging is that it causes the internal grain structure of the metal to flow and align with the shape of the part, rather than being cut or poured.
How it's done:
Heating: The metal is heated to a plastic state (below its melting point).
Shaping: Powerful forces are applied to deform the metal into the desired shape. This can be open-die forging (where the metal is shaped between simple dies) or closed-die (impression-die) forging, where the metal is forced into a cavity that defines the shape.
Cooling & Finishing: The forged part is cooled, and then typically undergoes machining to achieve the final dimensions, surface finish, and to create internal passages or threads.
Advantages of Forged Valves:
Superior Mechanical Properties: This is the primary advantage. The forging process refines the metal's grain structure, making it denser, more uniform, and free from internal porosity, shrinkage, or gas pockets. This translates to:
Higher Strength: Increased tensile strength, yield strength, and fatigue strength.
Improved Toughness: Better resistance to impact and fracture.
Enhanced Ductility: Ability to deform without fracturing.
Greater Reliability: Due to the absence of internal defects common in casting, forged valves are inherently more reliable and less prone to leaks or failures, especially under stress.
Thinner Walls: Because of their superior strength, forged valve bodies can often be designed with thinner wall sections while maintaining the required pressure ratings, which can sometimes lead to lighter valves.
Excellent for High-Pressure/High-Temperature Applications: Their robust nature makes them ideal for critical services in industries like oil and gas, petrochemicals, power generation, and aerospace where safety and performance are paramount.
Better Corrosion Resistance: A denser, more uniform grain structure can sometimes offer slightly better resistance to certain forms of corrosion.
Disadvantages of Forged Valves:
Higher Cost: Forging processes are more labor-intensive, require expensive tooling (especially for closed-die forging), and consume more energy per unit. Significant machining is often required after forging to create internal passages and seating surfaces.
Limited Design Complexity: Forging is best suited for relatively simpler, more uniform shapes. Creating intricate internal geometries, multiple branches, or very large, complex valve bodies can be challenging or impossible to do in a single forged piece, often requiring welding together multiple forged components.
Size Limitations: While large forgings exist, producing very large valve bodies as single forged units can be extremely expensive and challenging due to the immense forces required.
Typical Forged Valve Types: Gate valves, globe valves, check valves, and needle valves, especially in smaller to medium sizes and for high-pressure classes. Flanged-end and butt-weld end connections are common.
2. Cast Valves
Process: Casting involves pouring molten metal into a mold cavity that has been shaped to the desired form of the valve body. As the metal cools and solidifies within the mold, it takes on the mold's shape.
How it's done:
Mold Creation: A mold is typically made from sand, ceramic, or metal, with a cavity that matches the external shape of the valve body, and often cores to create internal passages.
Melting: Metal (e.g., cast iron, steel alloys, bronzes) is melted in a furnace.
Pouring: The molten metal is poured into the mold cavity.
Solidification: The metal cools and solidifies, shrinking as it does so.
Finishing: Once solid, the casting is removed from the mold, and any excess material (like risers or gates) is cut off. Machining is then performed to create precision surfaces, threads, and to ensure dimensional accuracy.
Advantages of Cast Valves:
Design Flexibility and Complexity: This is the greatest advantage. Casting can produce highly intricate and complex shapes, including integrated internal passages, multiple ports, and non-linear flow paths, which would be extremely difficult or impossible to achieve through forging without extensive and costly machining or welding of multiple parts.
Cost-Effectiveness for Complex/Large Parts: For large valves or designs with significant complexity, casting is generally more economical. The initial tooling cost for molds might be higher than some forging dies, but the per-unit cost can be lower, especially for high-volume production.
Versatility in Size: Casting is well-suited for producing very large valve bodies, where forging would be impractical or prohibitively expensive.
Material Versatility: A wide range of metals and alloys can be cast, including various grades of cast iron, carbon steel, stainless steel, and specialty alloys.
Disadvantages of Cast Valves:
Potential for Internal Defects: During solidification, molten metal can be susceptible to defects such as:
Porosity: Small voids or bubbles caused by trapped gases.
Shrinkage Cavities: Voids formed when metal shrinks during cooling.
Inclusions: Non-metallic impurities.
These defects can compromise mechanical properties and create potential leak paths.
Lower Mechanical Properties (Generally): Due to the potential for these defects and the inherent grain structure of cast metals (which is less refined than forged metals), cast valves generally exhibit lower tensile strength, impact strength, and fatigue resistance compared to their forged counterparts of the same material grade.
Thicker Walls: To compensate for the possibility of internal defects and to ensure sufficient strength, cast valve bodies often require thicker wall sections than forged bodies for a given pressure rating.
Quality Control Challenges: Detecting internal defects in castings requires rigorous inspection methods like X-ray, ultrasonic testing, or magnetic particle inspection, adding to the manufacturing overhead.
Typical Cast Valve Types: Ball valves, butterfly valves, plug valves, larger gate and globe valves, and highly specialized valves with complex geometries.
Conclusion
The choice between forged and cast valves is a critical engineering decision driven by the valve's application:
Forged valves are the preferred choice for high-pressure, high-temperature, critical, and severe service applications where maximum strength, integrity, and reliability are paramount, and where the design allows for it.
Cast valves are excellent for larger sizes, complex designs, and applications where moderate pressure and temperature ratings are sufficient, offering significant cost advantages and design flexibility.
Both manufacturing processes continue to evolve with advancements in metallurgy, computational modeling, and quality control, leading to ever more reliable and efficient valves for a vast array of industrial uses.
